Rental car accidents are more complicated than typical car crashes. When a collision involves a rented vehicle, questions quickly arise:
-
Who pays for the damage?
-
Is the rental company responsible?
-
Does insurance still apply?
-
What if the driver was from another state?
In California, liability depends on several factors, including who caused the accident, how the vehicle was rented, and whether any defects played a role.
Who Is Usually Responsible After a Rental Car Accident?
1. The Driver
In most cases, the person driving the rental car is responsible for the rental car accident, just as they would be in a personal vehicle.
If the driver was:
-
Distracted
-
Impaired
-
Violating traffic laws
They can be held personally liable for damages.
2. The Rental Car Company
Rental companies are usually not liable for a driver’s negligence but there are important exceptions.
They may be responsible if:
-
The vehicle was poorly maintained
-
Brakes, tires, or lights failed
-
A known defect was ignored
-
The car was unsafe to rent
California law requires rental companies to keep vehicles in safe operating condition.
3. The Vehicle Manufacturer
If a mechanical defect caused or contributed to the crash—such as brake failure or airbag malfunction—the manufacturer may be liable under product liability laws.
4. Another Driver
If someone else caused the crash, their insurance is primarily responsible even if you were in a rental car.
How Insurance Works in Rental Car Accidents
Rental car claims often involve multiple layers of coverage:
1. The Driver’s Personal Auto Insurance
Most California auto policies extend to rental vehicles.
2. Rental Car Insurance
Rental agencies offer optional coverage, including:
-
Collision Damage Waivers (CDW)
-
Liability coverage
-
Personal accident insurance
These policies may reduce or eliminate out-of-pocket costs.
3. Credit Card Coverage
Some credit cards provide rental coverage but often only if:
-
The rental was paid for with that card
-
The driver declined the rental company’s insurance
-
The cardholder followed all policy requirements
Coverage varies significantly by card issuer.
What If You’re Injured by Someone Driving a Rental Car?
If the at-fault driver was in a rental:
-
Their personal insurance applies first
-
Rental company coverage may apply second
-
The rental company itself is usually protected by federal law unless negligence is involved
This layered insurance structure often delays claims and makes legal guidance important.
Rental Car Accidents Involving Out-of-State Drivers
California sees millions of tourists each year. When an out-of-state driver causes a crash:
-
California law still applies
-
Their insurance must meet California minimums
-
Jurisdiction can become complex
These cases often involve delays and coverage disputes.
What to Do After a Rental Car Accident
-
Call police and request a report
-
Document the scene thoroughly
-
Photograph the rental agreement and vehicle
-
Seek medical care immediately
-
Avoid giving recorded statements
-
Preserve all rental paperwork
-
Contact an attorney before speaking to insurers
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I sue a rental car company directly?
Only if their negligence contributed to the crash (defective vehicle, poor maintenance, etc.).
What if the rental driver was uninsured?
Other insurance policies—yours, the rental company’s, or UM/UIM coverage—may apply.
Does rental insurance cover injuries?
Some policies do, but many only cover vehicle damage. Medical bills often fall under auto or health insurance.
What if I was a passenger in a rental car?
You may have claims against the driver, the rental company, or another motorist depending on fault.
Final Thoughts
Rental car accidents involve complex layers of liability, insurance coverage, and legal responsibility. Determining who pays—and how much—depends on the facts of the crash, the rental agreement, and the insurance policies involved.
Because multiple parties are often involved, these cases benefit from careful investigation and early legal guidance to ensure injured victims aren’t left covering costs that should be paid by others.
